Gill's dressing room exchange with Jaiswal - Who was at fault?

The viral run-out of Yashasvi Jaiswal in the second Test against West Indies has become more than a dismissal; it’s a debate. Jaiswal was dismissed after a messy mix-up early on Day 2 at the Arun Jaitley Stadium, and the moment instantly exploded across social media, with fans and pundits dissecting whether captain Shubman Gill was at fault.

What happened: The facts

Jaiswal came into Day 2 on 173 and was looking set for a double hundred when an early over produced a running mix-up. The confusion led to Jaiswal being run out for 175 — a dismissal that ended a potentially match-defining innings and left teammates and fans stunned. Video clips and eyewitness accounts show a brief but heated exchange in the dressing room afterwards, and Jaiswal later spoke to media about the “horrible mix-up.”

Why social media escalated it?

In the age of instant clips and hot takes, every frame gets a verdict. Clips of the mix-up, plus Jaiswal’s visible frustration on the field, created a narrative that Gill, who has been involved in run-out moments before, had again erred. That narrative quickly picked up pace on Twitter, Instagram and sports forums, with some users accusing Gill of poor judgment and others defending him. Media outlets tracked both the viral reaction and a stream of former players’ commentary.

Gill’s response: leadership or damage control?

Rather than let the story fester, Gill went straight to Jaiswal to clear the air in the dressing room — a move covered widely by outlets and social feeds. That gesture matters: it reframes the incident from a blame game to an internal team conversation and signals a captain trying to protect dressing-room harmony after a costly error. Multiple reports note the captain’s attempts to pacify an upset Jaiswal and manage media fallout.

How to judge who was at fault

Run-outs are often split-second disasters that involve communication, fatigue and split decisions. While Gill has had previous run-out controversies, video evidence and player statements from this match suggest the responsibility was shared and possibly not solely Gill’s. Analysts argue the proper takeaway is to learn from the error: tighten running calls, reinforce non-verbal signals, and keep composure under pressure.

Bottom line:

The Yashasvi Jaiswal run-out in the India vs West Indies 2nd Test ignited social media. While Shubman Gill faced scrutiny, his immediate approach to Jaiswal highlights captaincy that prioritises team unity. The incident is a reminder that run-out controversies rarely have a single villain, they’re a failure of communication in high-pressure cricket.

Also Watch: Yashasvi Jaiswal: Ignored in T20Is and ODIs, unstoppable in Tests