No Pant, No Punch? Can Dhruv Jurel bat if Pant can't?

India’s Test campaign at Lord’s hit a major roadblock as wicketkeeper-batter Rishabh Pant suffered a painful blow to his left index finger during the 34th over of England’s first innings. The injury occurred while Pant was collecting a ball down the leg side. Though he initially continued, he was soon forced off the field for treatment. The BCCI later confirmed that Pant is under medical supervision and being closely monitored by the team’s medical staff.

In Pant’s absence, substitute Dhruv Jurel has taken over wicketkeeping duties. However, as per the MCC’s post-2017 laws, while a substitute can replace a wicketkeeper for fielding under genuine medical conditions, they are not permitted to bat. This means that unless Pant returns, India will effectively bat one man short in the remainder of the Test.

And this isn’t just a tactical setback—it’s a serious dent to India’s momentum. Pant has been instrumental in India’s strong showing this series. His twin centuries in the opening Test at Leeds set the tone early, showcasing not just class but clutch temperament. In the second Test, his 65 off 58 balls in the second innings gave India the acceleration they needed to set a competitive target for the hosts.

Beyond the numbers, Pant brings an X-factor that’s hard to quantify. His voice behind the stumps, constant banter, and smart field placements have all played a role in unsettling opposition batters and supporting Indian bowlers. His presence keeps the energy high and the opponents guessing.

More than stats, it’s Pant’s presence—that voice behind the stumps, the mischief, the tactical calls, the pressure he builds just by chirping in the batter’s ear. Without him, the game just feels quieter... flatter.

Gill may be the top scorer, but it’s Pant’s unpredictability and fearless intent that’s been India’s edge. s.

If Pant is ruled out, the psychological impact on both teams could be significant. For India, it’s the loss of a game-changer. For England, it’s a window of opportunity.

The coming days will reveal more about his availability. But one thing is clear—without Rishabh Pant, India’s edge in this high-stakes series takes a serious hit.

Also Watch: Red ball or red flag? Why is everyone mad at the Dukes ball